Barndoor Bulletin: We’ll govern again, don’t know where, don’t know when….

Barndoor Bulletin: We’ll govern again, don’t know where, don’t know when….

This year’s Conservative Party Conference was almost as diverse in perspective as Birmingham’s many neighbourhoods.  It was a curiously upbeat affair.  The tone exemplified by 1940s refrains. Not just the obligatory Churchill references, but also two blue-clad singers belted out big band favourites in the middle of Monday’s afternoon.

Yet despite this jollity; even to casual observers, it was an obviously ill attended affair.

For a start, the exhibition was a third of the normal size.  Large areas of this hall had been commandeered for other purposes.  However, the western world’s oldest political party has deep roots.  The canyon-like Birmingham International Conference Centre (ICC) did fill out as the week went on. No mean feat in this cavernous space which has more than a passing resemblance to the impossible drawings of artist M.C. Esher. Yet never was it so easy to buy a drink at the conference bar.  Never mind find a lunchtime seat at the ICC’s solitary Starbucks.

The atmosphere was both flat and also optimistic.  On the one hand excited for the future.  Yet praying a general election wasn’t just around the corner.  This jarring juxtaposition is perhaps only explicable by the fact that the Government has started making mistakes.  Leaving out the sort of red meat the tax-cutting Thatcherite lions of the Tories have cravedfor decades.  There was an unequivocal belief that the Government is in trouble, and that the British public would be repulsed by its 1970s socialist agenda.  Together with equally unimpeachable view that somehow Reform was doomed to fail.  Hence it was about to ‘turn out nice again’ to channel the 1940s catchphrase of George Formby.

Even if the buoyant Burnham is heading for a spell on the rocks, the Conservative party is far from ready to exploit any Government woes.  Firstly, it doesn’t even have enough candidates.  A situation so bad even sitting MPs have yet to be readopted.  Worse, the ‘grand old party’ iscaught on the horns of a dilemma exemplified by Kemi’s speech. Conservatives have a battle on two fronts.  Boris’ “red wall” vital to winning a majority is firmly red again with Farage’s self-styled People’s Army all too often in pole position.  Yet in the Tory heartlands of the Home Counties Team Kemi must also hold off Ed Davey’s insurgent Lib Dems.

This challenge would have been familiar to another leader who was referenced in homage on the highlight of this conference, The Birmingham Tapestry. This AI-produced tapestry was genuinely witty and impressive.  Although, the lack of related merchandise until the final dayof conference betrayed its last-minute nature.

Harold Godwinson’s battles on two fronts did not end well.  While he successfully vanquished the Danes at Stamford Bridge, he lost to the Normans in the south.  Team Kemi will be hoping that history doesn’t repeat itself – but the polls suggest she could do even worse, with several projecting the Conservatives will lose seats from what is an already record low base.

What was also striking across conference was the conspicuous cult of personality around Kemi Badenoch.  Few, if any, other members of the shadow cabinet were featured without some sort of deferential reference or homage to the all-present leader. Only her face and name were present on said Tapestry. Next time you’re listening to one of their spokespeople,count for yourself as to how many times they reference “Kemi”!

This is a dramatic departure from the leaders of previous years and a curious tactic for the party to place all its eggs in one basket.  Badenoch’s majority is only 2,610 in her new(ish) North West Essex seat.  Yet for all this talk of “Kemistry” her 30,000-word pamphlet entitled “The Right Way” was nowhere to be seen at conference.  Surely, she should be handing out this modern-day “Tamworth Manifesto” to every delegate? Leaving it on every shelf (and the ICC has many). It was nowhere to be seen.

There were signs that the Conservatives are grappling with the challenges ahead.  There was a lot of concern about the state of the economy, the high cost of energy and the parlous state of the UK’s defences.  But then came the gaffe.  Whose idea was it to book Badenoch ontoNick Ferrari’s LBC show without ensuring she had the fullest of briefings?  Ferrari has made a decades-long career tripping up politicians of all colours by asking them basic facts and numbers.  Yet his obvious lines of attack ripped through the “Britania Shield” faster than aRussian hypersonic missile.

While the delegates clapped endlessly during the leader’s speech; the commentariat were less impressed with the content.  The headline-grabbing policy on Inheritance Tax abolition on family homes certainly grabbed core audiences such as the Mail and Telegraph.  But the prominence given to tax reliefs for senior professionals earning over £100,000 a year from a party supposedly targeting SMEs and white van man remains a mystery.

That said, there were moments of passion.  Badenoch came alive when drawing some clear red lines between the Conservatives and Reform on British identity and again with Labour on economics and the national debt.

Badenoch might currently lack the rhetorical flourish of Burnham; but it was a solid performance.  The Leader of the Opposition is clearly growing in confidence, which might give Labour and Reform’s planners pause for thought.

The Conservative Party may well have begun its long march on the winding road back to office.  However, if this conference were anything to go by that may be a much longer road than many delegates expect. It’s fair to say that she has most of the dyed-in-the-wool Tories onside. The problem is she needs far more than that to win an election. And it’s still hard to see where any other votes are going to come from.

Barndoor Strategy

October 2026.